Tithe.ly Review: Real Cost, Complaints and Alternatives

The lobby of a small church with a glowing giving kiosk on a stand, a mother, father and two children standing in front of it as the father taps the screen

By The Solomon Wealth Code Editorial Team · Published · Updated · Reviewed for biblical and financial accuracy.

Tithe.ly powers giving for over 37,000 churches — but is it the right platform for tithers? An honest 2026 review of fees, the donor and church experience, recurring giving, and the alternatives worth considering.

Tithe.ly (also written Tithely) is a solid giving platform for small and mid-size churches. The software starts free, and the real cost is the processing fee: 2.9% + $0.30 on every card gift and 1% + $0.30 on every bank (ACH) gift. A church that moves its regular givers to ACH keeps roughly two-thirds of that fee.

A lobby kiosk is one of several ways Tithe.ly takes a gift.

This review covers what the platform does, what it costs a church of three different sizes, the complaints that come up most, and the alternatives worth a look. It is written for two readers: the pastor or treasurer choosing a tool, and the member deciding how to give.

Apply this study

Settle the amount first, then the platform. Run your giving math with our Tithe Calculator. Open it now →

Tithe.ly pricing as of October 2026

Does Tithe.ly charge a fee? Yes, on every gift. The Free Giving plan has no monthly price, and the fee comes out of each donation. Tithe.ly’s pricing page lists the figures below as of October 2026. Confirm them on the page before you sign.

ItemListed price
Credit or debit card gift2.9% + $0.30
ACH bank gift1% + $0.30
American Express gift3.5% + $0.30
Free Giving plan$0 a month (text-to-give is an extra $19 a month on this plan)
All-Access plan$119 a month, includes daily deposits
Church Management$72 a month
Mobile Church App$89 a month
Website$19 a month

The page also states there are no monthly minimums or scaling fees, and donors can choose to cover the fees so the church receives the full gift.

Tithe.ly finance workflow

For the treasurer, the question is what happens after the gift lands. Tithe.ly lists a QuickBooks Online integration, offline gift recording for cash and check, check scanning with remote deposit, recording of business and pass-through gifts, contribution and gift reports, end-of-year tax receipts, CSV exports and bank deposit reports that most accounting platforms can import. Deposits are weekly by default, and daily deposits can be requested. Refunds are issued from the admin dashboard. Ask for a demo with your own chart of accounts before you commit.

What Tithe.ly is

Tithe.ly is a U.S. faith-based donation and church management platform. It offers online giving on the web, a mobile app, text-to-give, in-person kiosks, recurring gifts, a church website builder, a church management system (ChMS), live streaming and giving analytics. The company describes itself as serving more than 100,000 churches, and it built its product for congregations only.

The rates below match the numbers in our Tithe.ly fees breakdown. They reflect published pricing as of September 2026. Confirm current rates with Tithe.ly before you sign, because pricing pages change.

Pros and cons at a glance

AreaProsCons
PriceGiving software is free to start; no monthly fee for the basic planCard gifts cost about 3%; paid modules add $89-$199 a month in the tiers we have seen listed
Giving channelsWeb, app, text, kiosk and recurring gifts in one dashboardKiosk hardware and some add-ons cost extra
Donor experienceSimple mobile app; optional cover-the-fees checkbox lets the church receive 100% of the giftDonors who did not expect the checkbox can find it confusing
Church managementMembers, attendance, groups and giving under one loginThe ChMS is adequate for small churches and thin for large ones
SetupMost churches go live within a day or twoNew accounts can see payout holds while the processor reviews them
SupportPhone and email help; generally well ratedEmail waits grow at Christmas and Easter

What Tithe.ly really costs by church size

A percentage hides the dollars, so here is the same platform at three sizes. The assumptions are stated in the first two columns, and the fee is the card rate (2.9% + $0.30) against the ACH rate (1% + $0.30). The $0.30 is charged on every gift, which is why the number of gifts matters.

Church sizeOnline giving a monthGifts a monthAll card, per monthAll ACH, per monthSaved per year with ACH
Small (about 75 attenders)$5,00050$160$65$1,140
Mid-size (about 300)$25,000250$800$325$5,700
Large (about 1,000)$100,000800$3,140$1,240$22,800

These figures cover processing only. Paid software tiers are billed on top. Real churches land between the two columns, since most receive a mix of card and bank gifts. The point holds at every size: the payment method a giver picks changes the church’s cost more than the choice of platform does.

Common Tithe.ly complaints and how much weight they deserve

Search “Tithe.ly complaints” and the same handful of themes repeat. Here is what church finance teams and donors most often raise.

  • “The fees are higher than we expected.” The fee is per transaction, so a church that receives mostly card gifts gives up about 3% of every dollar. Moving recurring givers to ACH is the biggest fix. The fee breakdown shows the dollars.
  • “Payouts took longer than promised.” Deposits usually arrive within a couple of business days. New accounts and flagged transactions get held for review, a pattern every payment processor shares.
  • “Support was slow to respond.” This is the most frequent complaint by volume. Email tickets pile up in December and around Easter, and urgent payout problems move faster by phone.
  • “Refunding or correcting a gift is awkward.” Refunds work from the admin dashboard, and the processing fee on the original gift is not returned.
  • “The ChMS feels bolted on.” Fair. Giving is the strong product, and church management suits small and mid-size churches better than large ones.
  • “Donors are confused by the fee-coverage checkbox.” Churches that explain it on the giving page see fewer complaints than churches that surprise donors at checkout.
  • “How do I cancel?” The free giving plan carries no contract to cancel. Paid modules are billed monthly, so check your own agreement for the notice terms, and export your donor and recurring-gift data before you leave.

None of these ends the conversation alone. The combination that should worry a church is heavy card giving plus slow support during a payout problem, because that is when the fee math and the service gaps add up.

Tithe.ly alternatives

  • Pushpay suits larger churches that want deep analytics and a comprehensive ChMS, at a higher price.
  • Givelify offers a very simple donor-first app with the same headline rates as Tithe.ly and no monthly fee.
  • Planning Center Giving makes sense when the church already runs Planning Center for people and services, and it publishes a lower card rate (2.15% + $0.30).
  • Breeze ChMS charges a flat monthly price that includes giving and works well for small and mid-size churches.
  • Subsplash bundles an app, giving, streaming and church management.
  • Vanco and Easy Tithe are long-standing church donation processors.
  • Direct ACH or bank transfer costs the church the least, for donors comfortable with a routing-number setup.

Side-by-side rates for five platforms, plus the cost of switching, are in our church giving app fees comparison. For the wider field of apps, see tithing app reviews. Switching carries one real risk: recurring gift profiles rarely transfer between processors, so plan a re-enrollment campaign or the savings disappear into lapsed gifts.

How to choose for your church

  • Small church (under 100 attenders): the Tithe.ly free plan or Breeze keeps cost near zero.
  • Mid-size church (100-500): compare Tithe.ly paid tiers, Planning Center Giving and Breeze on total annual cost.
  • Large church (500+): get quotes from Pushpay and Subsplash and negotiate, since volume changes the rate.
  • Multi-site or many funds: confirm fund tracking and campus attribution before you commit.
  • Heavy ChMS need: choose the church management system you actually want, then add the giving module from the same vendor.

For givers: how to give wisely on Tithe.ly or any platform

  • Choose ACH when you can. The fee is about 1% against about 3% for a card, so more of your tithe reaches ministry.
  • Cover the fee if your church offers the checkbox, so the church receives 100% of your gift.
  • Set recurring giving for payday. Firstfruits (Proverbs 3:9) work best when the gift goes out before other spending.
  • Choose your base with the gross or net tithe guide.
  • Keep the year-end statement for tax records, and ask a tax professional how to treat any fee you covered.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • What is the payout schedule, and what triggers a hold? Ask for the answer in writing.
  • Which modules are free and which are billed? Get a line-by-line price list for the church’s exact setup.
  • Can we export donor and recurring-gift data? The answer decides how hard it will be to leave later.
  • How is fee coverage displayed to donors? Preview the giving form the way a first-time giver sees it.
  • Who answers the phone during a Sunday outage? A named support contact is worth more than a lower rate.

Who should skip Tithe.ly

Churches already deep in Planning Center will usually do better with Planning Center Giving, because one system and one login save staff hours. Large congregations with heavy reporting needs should price Pushpay and Subsplash before deciding. When only a handful of members give digitally, a direct bank-transfer instruction costs nothing and works fine.

A word on the theology of the tool

Scripture names no payment method. It does teach the rhythm. Paul asked the Corinthians to set something aside “on the first day of every week” according to their income (1 Corinthians 16:2), and automatic digital giving keeps that habit steady. Proverbs 3:9 asks for firstfruits, and a recurring gift on payday is the simplest way to meet it.

The verdict

Tithe.ly earns a recommendation for small and mid-size churches that want a free start, several giving channels and a simple donor experience. Larger churches with heavy reporting needs should price Pushpay and Planning Center. Whichever platform you pick, set ACH as the default and review the paid modules every quarter. The tool matters less than the giver’s consistency.

Internal study path

Set up firstfruits giving

Automate the tithe this week.

Whatever platform your church uses, schedule your recurring tithe for payday. Open the Tithe Calculator to set the right amount.

Open the Tithe Calculator →

The Solomon Wealth Code on YouTube